Family Court Reform / Vermont

Best Interest of the Child Definition Act

Explore the proposal and choose your location for region-specific information.

Vermont Bill Status
Not Startedi

Best Interest of the Child Definition Act

Defining the Best Interests of the Child

Establish clear, evidence-based standards for decisions affecting children and their families.

Why This Bill Matters

Establishes a clear statutory definition of 'best interest of the child,' requiring courts to base custody decisions on evidence — not assumptions, speculation, or personal preference. Courts retain full authority to protect children from abuse, neglect, family violence, and harm; this definition ensures that authority is exercised consistently and reviewably across every state.

Evidence-Based Decisions

Requires courts to apply enumerated statutory criteria based on facts in evidence, not judicial assumptions or personal preferences — creating consistent, predictable, and appealable outcomes for families.

Equal Protection for Both Parents

By codifying objective factors, the act prevents gender bias and personal judicial preferences from influencing which parent receives custody — while preserving courts' full authority to act when a child's safety is at risk.

Children's Wellbeing at the Center

The statutory definition prioritizes the child's physical safety, emotional health, educational stability, and the right to maintain meaningful relationships with both parents. Protection from abuse, neglect, family violence, coercive control, and substantial harm is fully preserved.

A Clear Standard, Not a Loophole

When 'best interest' is undefined, outcomes depend more on judicial temperament than on facts — and that uncertainty harms children and families alike. This act requires courts to apply a clear, evidence-based standard. Courts keep full authority to protect children from abuse and harm. What they lose is the ability to make arbitrary decisions with no accountability.

Evidence, not preference. Consistency, not luck. ⚖️
LEGISLATIVE PRECEDENT

UCCJEA § 102 & ALI Principles of the Law of Family Dissolution

Multiple uniform acts and legal scholarship have called for codified best-interest standards. This bill converts best practices from case law into binding statutory language — ensuring every family court judge applies the same transparent, reviewable criteria.

Contact Your Legislator